Home
Film index
Previous film
Next film
Judy Garland Database

Film Review: Presenting Lily Mars

DVD
VHS
Soundtrack
Posters

Presenting Lily Mars

MGM, 1943 (BW, 104 minutes, Production No. 1264)

An ambitious talented girl from a small midwestern town crashes Broadway but before she triumphs she has to learn the hard way that no one becomes a star overnight. When Lily Mars catches the eye - and the heart - of a famous producer, she thinks she has it made, especially when the star of the show walks out in a fit of temperament. But Lily has to face the hard reality that she isn't ready for stardom - for a while.

[from MGM press sheet]

See DVD Review

Crew

Producer: Joe Pasternak
Director: Norman Taurog
Screenplay: Richard Connell and Gladys Lehman
Based on the novel by Booth Tarkington
Music Director: George Stoll
Song Score: Jurmann, Webster, Harburg, Lane, and Edens
Choreography: Ernst Matray
Art Direction: Cedric Gibbons and Harry McAfee
Set Decoration: Edwin B. Willis
Gowns: Shoup
Sound: Douglas Shearer, Norwood A. Fenton
Special Effects: Warren Newcombe
Director of Photography: Joseph Ruttenberg
Film Editing: Albert Akst

Filmed: September 1942 - March 1943 (Judy was 20 years old)
Released: April 1943

Cast

Judy Garland ... Lily Mars
Van Heflin ... John ("Thorny") Thornway
Fay Bainter ... Mrs. Thornway
Richard Carlson ... Owen Vail
Spring Byington ... Mrs. Mars
Martra Eggerth ... Isobel Rekay
Connie Gilchrist ... Frankie
Leonid Kinskey ... Leo
Patricia Barker ... Poppy
Janet Chapman ... Violet
Annabelle Logan ... Rosie
Douglas Croft ... Davey
Ray McDonald ... Charlie Potter
Tommy Dorsey and His Orchestra ... Themselves
Bob Crosby and His Orchestra ... Themselves
The Wilde Twins ... Themselves
Charles Walters ... Specialty Dancer (Judy's dance partner in finale)
Joe Yule ... Mike, the stage doorman
Gus Schilling ... Scotty
Almira Sessions ... Boarding House Owner

Musical Program

[0:24] Is It Love (Or the Gypsy in Me?) (sung by Marta Eggerth)
[0:33] Tom, Tom, the Piper's Son (sung by Judy Garland)
[0:44] "Russian Number" (sung by MGM Studio Chorus)
[0:48] Ev'ry Little Movement (Has a Meaning All Its Own) (sung by Judy Garland and Mary Kent dubbing for Connie Gilchrist)
[0:50] When I Look at You (sung by Marta Eggerth)
[1:06] When I Look at You (sung by Marta Eggerth)
[1:08] When You Think of Lovin', Baby, Think of Me (sung by Bob Crosby and His Orchestra with The Wilde Twins)
[1:10] When I Look at You (ballad version, sung by Judy Garland with Bob Crosby and His Orchestra)
[1:12] Caro Nome (When I Look at You) (Giuseppe Verdi / Webster-Jurmann) (comedy version, sung by Judy Garland with Bob Crosby and His Orchestra)
[1:24] Russian Rhapsody (sung by Judy Garland)
[1:34] Russian Rhapsody (sung by Marta Eggerth)
[1:38] Finale:
[1:38] Where There's Music (sung by Judy Garland and MGM Studio Chorus)
[1:40] Three O'Clock in the Morning (sung by Judy Garland and Chorus)
[1:41] Broadway Rhythm (sung and danced by Judy Garland, Charles Walters, MGM Studio Chorus and Tommy Dorsey and Orchestra)

[cut] Paging Mr. Greenback (sung by Judy Garland and MGM Studio Chorus)
[cut] St. Louis Blues (sung by Judy Garland and MGM Studio Chorus)
[cut] It's a Long Way to Tipperary (sung by Judy Garland and MGM Studio Chorus)
[cut] In the Shade of the Old Apple Tree (sung by Judy Garland and MGM Studio Chorus)
[cut] Don't Sit Under the Apple Tree (With Anyone Else But Me) (sung by Charles Walters)


see soundtrack anthology CD review

Notes

Judy began work on Lily Mars while retakes were still being made for For Me and My Gal, and began work on Girl Crazy before completing Lily Mars.

Joseph Pasternak had just come to MGM from Universal after making a huge success of Deanna Durbin's early films. He would often rave about Judy, calling her "an authentic cinema genius, born with what might be called perfect theatrical pitch."

Annabelle Logan, who played Lily's sister Rosie, later became a jazz singer by the name of Annie Ross.

Musical outtakes from this film are included in the laser disc set: "Judy Garland: The Golden Years at M-G-M," MGM/UA Home Video ML104869.

Musical outtakes from this film are included on the compact disc: "Judy Garland: Collectors' Gems from the M-G-M Films," Rhino R2 72543.

See Judy Garland Movies on Video for information about the latest releases of home video and sountrack.

See Class Act for more information on this and other classic films.

Critical Response

"Metro-Goldwyn-Mayer, which dotes on young Judy Garland, is again having her show off her best points ... Miss Garland is fresh and pretty, she has a perky friendliness that is completely disarming, and she sings and dances according to the mood - sometimes raucous jive, sometimes sweet little ballads that turn out to be quite enchanting. No doubt about it, Miss Garland is a gifted young lady."

- The New York Times, April 30, 1943

Presenting Lily Mars is a conventional screen version of 73-year-old Booth Tarkington's tale of a stage-struck small-town girl. This juvenile darling (Judy Garland) gets to Broadway before you can say Jake Shubert, marries a great producer (Van Heflin) and is soon seen swaying in black tulle in a super-sumptuous musical show staged by the lucky fellow.

- Time Magazine

Memorable Lines

John:
"You've heard of Sarah Bernhardt,
she really was a dilly.
But Sarah Bernhardt couldn't compare
to the gal that's known as Lily!"

Poppy:
"Congratulations, Lily dear
upon the start of your career.
We love you best of all the stars
We're proud of you, Miss Lily Mars!"

Mrs. Mars (speaking excitedly to a news reporter on the telephone): "My name is Lily Mars' mother!"

Supplemental Material

Supplement 1: Costume tests
Supplement 2: Movie stills
Supplement 3: Publicity stills

See DVD Review


Presenting Lily Mars DVD
Buy DVD


See DVD Review


Presenting Lily Mars VHS
Buy VHS



Song score included on soundtrack anthology
Buy soundtrack anthology



Presenting Lily Mars Posters
Buy Posters



Presenting Lily Mars Books
Buy Books



Judy Garland in finale scene


Shhhh!!! Lily is trying to sneak into Thornton's Theatre


Thronton tries to teach Lily the lead part


Publicity photo: Van Heflin and Judy Garland

Home   Film index   Previous film   Next film
Judy Garland Database ©1995-2007 Jim Johnson - see copyright statement